[Rational Mind]

Paid blog commenting is ok, however, if the commentator has to write only good comments, that will be a fake comments. The commentators should have a freedom to speak their mind.

[sofs]

Paid blog commenting is ok, however, if the commentator has to write only good comments, that will be a fake comments. The commentators should have a freedom to speak their mind.

That is promotion for you Not really, People are okay with asking questions so they can add more information. I usually add information to blogs on paid blogging sites or ask a question or two.

[suny]

I even point to the improvement possible or suggest few ways that can make things better for the one who asked for paid comments. Maybe they find something worth while in my suggestions.

[johnywalker]

paid blog commenting is just like paid forum posting. There are forums that drive activities by paying the users and there are blogs that drive comments by paying.

[Rational Mind]

It makes not sense whether you are paying for contents (posts, comments), what ultimately counts is your website has useful and informative contents.

[kat82]

I have worked as a paid commentator on some site. I don't think it is bad if the commentator mentions that he is a paid commentator.

Whether it is mentioned or not, truth remains is a paid commenter. I don't have many commenters though with huge traffic. What matters to me is traffic since not all posts require comments.

[anilmr]

Forumcoin isn't listed as a paid to click website, I think that there is nothing wrong in this as long as they don't click on adsene ads.

Yes, you are right when you say that Adsense won't penalise you as long as the person who has been paid to comment on the blogpost does not click the Adsense Ads - but how can the Adsense find that out? If someone pays me to comment on his/her blog, I might as well click an ad or two if it helps the person who has hired me to do a job.

[JASPREET]

There is nothing wrong in that but I think there should be genuine comments too because we cannot pay for the comments all the time and it can be expensive.

[aivan21]

You don't penalized by google by only this thing, but be sure that your post is original copied on other website.

[Mika]

I think It is ok to have paid commentators for your blog posts. But to mention this publically is not a good idea. When forums can have paid posters even when they are displaying google ads, what's the problem with bloggers having paid commentators.

[Kei]

I don't think paid commenting is a bad idea. As long as it's quality posts. That's what postloop and forum wheel did and these were very regulated.

[Mika]

I don't think paid commenting is a bad idea. As long as it's quality posts. That's what postloop and forum wheel did and these were very regulated.

We are posting on paid to post forums and these forums are using Adsense. If there was anything wrong with paid commenting, these forums would have never existed.

[skysnap]

I know many who are paying for the youtube commenting. And that is also a good thing for anyone who wants to earn income. its in cents but better than nothing.

[Treborika]

I think you are doing the right thing. So long as the posters make sensible posts you are good to go with that.

[jobless dude]

Paid blog commenting is good idea but they should click your Adsense ads. That against the terms of Adsense. If you pay users for their visit or action on your site, then it is taken as incentive publisher. You've have to change your site setting incentive publisher to getting any issues due to abnormal metrics. If a site is incentive, there might be higher chance a click might comes from same IP.

[augusta]

I think you are doing the right thing. So long as the posters make sensible posts you are good to go with that.

That's what really matter at this point. Just sensible and valuable comments and that's will be enough.